I could sense the audience’s growing confusion. We were just a few minutes into my BIG social session and brows were creasing. Why, people wondered, were we watching a video of a young John Cleese shouting at Michael Palin about a seemingly expired Norwegian Blue parrot?
Here’s why.
Russell Cartwright is a former NHS comms leader now working in behaviour change. He has said organic social media is dead like the famous Python parrot. Russell argues that comms teams are wasting precious time chasing organic reach when a fraction of the effort and a modest ad spend would deliver far greater impact for less hassle.
Then you have folks like Simon Binns (formerly of LADbible, now heading up content at GOV.UK) insisting that organic social media is very far from dead and has been having a hiatus. He says unfashionable Facebook is being overlooked and can still deliver engagement bangers. And he says you don’t need video; with creativity, relevance and relatability, static image posts can fly.
To see where the room stood, we staged a bit of chaotic “dead parrot polling.” I asked the audience to get on their feet and pick a corner depending on how they felt: dead, resting, or something else. It certainly got people moving and talking!
The good news is hardly anyone believed organic social media is truly dead; but plenty had concerns about the changing algorithms and how to meet the challenges this brings to public sector comms.


