Skip to main content

Reflections from BIG Social: is organic social a dead parrot or just resting?

13 November 2026
7 min read

I could sense the audience’s growing confusion. We were just a few minutes into my BIG social session and brows were creasing.  Why, people wondered, were we watching a video of a young John Cleese shouting at Michael Palin about a seemingly expired Norwegian Blue parrot?

Here’s why.

Russell Cartwright is a former NHS comms leader now working in behaviour change. He has said organic social media is dead like the famous Python parrot. Russell argues that comms teams are wasting precious time chasing organic reach when a fraction of the effort and a modest ad spend would deliver far greater impact for less hassle.

Then you have folks like Simon Binns (formerly of LADbible, now heading up content at GOV.UK) insisting that organic social media is very far from dead and has been having a hiatus. He says unfashionable Facebook is being overlooked and can still deliver engagement bangers. And he says you don’t need video; with creativity, relevance and relatability, static image posts can fly.

To see where the room stood, we staged a bit of chaotic “dead parrot polling.” I asked the audience to get on their feet and pick a corner depending on how they felt: dead, resting, or something else. It certainly got people moving and talking!

The good news is hardly anyone believed organic social media is truly dead; but plenty had concerns about the changing algorithms and how to meet the challenges this brings to public sector comms.

For me, the first step to move forwards is to confront some hard truths; taking the red pill, as I call it. The old social media hacks and heuristics don’t hold up under data scrutiny. Best time to post? Forget it. Today, with non-linear, AI-driven feeds serving up content from three days or even two weeks ago based on user interests and habits, obsessing over timing is pretty pointless. 

Similarly, viewing a video as a short cut to glory is misplaced. I’ve looked at thousands of data points for public sector organisations across the UK. The data strongly suggests that the performance boost for a video versus an image is often marginal. Video isn’t a silver bullet. Other factors in the content seem to matter much more.

Over the past few years I’ve been distilling insight from forensic deep dive data audits across dozens of public sector organisations, slowly building and refining a typology of ‘what works?’ – or maybe ‘what still works?’ – on organic social.

I’ve tried to go beyond topic-based categories which would make the typology unhelpful for organisations that don’t deliver anything related to that topic (for example, the perennial hot buttons of recycling, parking or road closures).

While algorithms evolve constantly, I’ve sought to boil down my typology for success to content types that I see cutting through and securing higher engagement time and time again.

A typology of successful organic content

Distilled from in-depth data analysis of the outputs of more than a dozen public sector organisations.

A typology of successful organic content
Content type For example
Urgent updates Extreme weather, serious travel disruption, environmental issues
New and shiny New facilities and investment, anticipated or here today (ideally with visuals)
Area wins Positive news for the area, including awards and recognition (for both people and place)
Sneak peek A look behind the scenes, something not usually seen and surprising. “I did not know that!”
Civic pride Local events, successes and assets that people feel proud of
Everyday heroes Everyday people doing great things, real people’s stories and achievements (can work for staff as well as residents, and animals!). Note: not generally senior leaders or elected officials.
Remarkable Stories that would literally make people remark: oooh, fancy that, haha, awww, wow, grrrr!, great!, nice one, what??, errrr…
Something in it for me A tangible personal gain: giveaways, free events and opportunities to be part of something unique
Affects me and many New rules, proposals and occurrences with capacity to affect a significant number of people

I’ve landed on nine categories (see above). But to the audience at BIG Social I recommend trying to work these three in particular into their approach to organic content;

  1. Everyday heroes: Stories of ordinary and relatable people from our communities (and yes this can include animals!) doing great things. Would not normally include corporate leaders.
  2. The ‘remarkable’: Content that literally makes people ‘remark’, out loud or to someone next to them, whether that be in surprise, disgust or joy. Making people comment is key to making organic social posts go anywhere these days. As I told the audience in Birmingham, the only thing worse than everyone talking about you is no-one talking about you!
  3. Sneak peeks: A look ‘behind the scenes’, something not usually seen, seen before and/or surprising, that might make someone say “I did not know that!”. Topics for these can often seem mundane to those in the thick of it, but can be endlessly fascinating – and shareable – to the outside world.

So I have a typology that I’ve thought long and hard about. I am inviting people to engage with it and feed back. And I’m totally open to it being challenged and evolved.

But for Joe Masa and the team at Stockport Council, it does seem to resonate.

Joe walked the room through how Stockport made the shift away from more passive corporate messaging toward giving residents an actual reason to care.

  • Civic pride wins: When Stockport was named fourth in Time Out’s coolest neighbourhoods in the UK, the council didn’t just report this; they leaned into local pride. The metric that mattered most wasn’t impressions, but neighbours tagging neighbours in the comments to celebrate (and sometimes query!) the ranking. Similarly, announcing a new railway station saw their Council Leader delivering an informal, engaging piece to camera, emerging from behind a bush.
  • “This affects me”: Nothing unites or divides a local population quite like bin collections. When Stockport introduced a paid garden waste subscription, the social comments were ferocious. Comms braced for the onslaught with airtight reactive FAQs. Councillors panicked about the backlash, but the comms team held their nerve. The result? 19,000 permits sold in weeks, climbing to over 65,000 permits and generating £3.7 million for local services. The takeaway is critical. But negative commentary isn’t inherently a comms failure if it drives the public action required – which echoes my point above about no-one talking about you being a problem.
  • The death of the toolkit: Perhaps Joe’s most striking example was Men’s Health Week. Stockport was offered a standard corporate campaign toolkit, templated graphics and uniform copy. A toolkit post they ran pulled four likes and three shares. But alongside it, their colleague Karen went out with a smartphone to film a local lad named Adrian running past recognisable local landmarks to the Rocky theme. Edited with CapCut, that video earned 91,000 views, 52,000 reach, and an outpouring of genuinely supportive comments.

The comparison between the typology-ticking Stockport Rocky video and the standard toolkit approach is worth highlighting. 

When regional or national bodies distribute identical graphics and text across twenty local partners, the algorithm doesn’t see collective solidarity. Forget the ‘hey, let’s create a critical mass’ tactics of yesteryear; my work suggests platforms like Meta will simply see this as repetitive spam.

I believe today’s AI-driven algorithms are now super adept at detecting the repetitive. If twenty organisations publish identical creatives within a short window, a platform will very likely detect this spammy content and ensure very few people see it.

If you want key campaigns to succeed, the centralised corporate toolkit must be binned off. Take the objectives and core messages, and tell the story through your own lens, in a way that makes sense to your own audience.

During our Q&As, we heard and discussed how;

  • Video doesn’t need a broadcast studio: Stockport’s highest performing videos were shot on work phones and cut on basic editing apps. Data suggests polished corporate video with idents or graphics can be costly, slow to produce, and often performs worse than raw, authentic, human footage.
  • Saying “no” is a skill:  If an internal service request doesn’t provide a human angle, local relevance, or a genuine reason for residents to care, organic social might be the wrong channel. Put it on the website or include it in a newsletter; find places where the key message will reach the people it is intended for – and this might include some paid activity.
  • Build hypotheses to avoid drowning in data: If you have limited capacity to review analytics to inform tactics, don’t wander aimlessly through lots of data. Use the Orlo insights tools, if you have them, to get to what matters. Form some specific hypotheses and state your hunches; “Authentic photos will generate more comments than branded stock images”, for example. Then test with A/B variations.

So organic social media isn’t dead. But low-effort, low-value organic social media content certainly is.

You don’t get something for nothing any more. The days of scheduling generic stuff into the void and getting a result, or making a dull video to titillate the algorithm are long gone.

You need to be constantly data-informed and insights-suave to see the subtle changes in social performance. Audit meticulously and critically using deep data dives when you feel things aren’t working, challenging received wisdom and long-standing tropes.

Keep your storytelling authentic, surprising and remarkable. Use the typology as a guide to help you. Give your community and audiences a reason to care.

And give the algorithm no excuse to penalise you by avoiding some classic low-engagement traps.

My big thanks to Joe Masa from Stockport for joining the session. For more ideas on how to use data and insights to power your communications, head to my website.

Founder of Whetstone Communications

Alex Waddington is the founder of Whetstone Communications. A journalist by training, he is an award-winning leader with deep experience of strategic communications and marketing in top universities, a major police force, and an international charity.

He is a passionate advocate for data-in-communications, using it to help ambitious in-house teams plan campaigns, understand strengths and weaknesses, and tell stories.